Sel et Poivre – Neighborhood Restaurant for Everyone

The disappearance of small family businesses in New York – especially restaurants on the Upper East Side — has recently accelerated. Rents have soared and unless a restaurateur owns the building, he/she eventually departs. Just this week, Mon Petit Café, on Lexington Avenue, closed due to “sky high rent.” So it’s a double pleasure to toast the food, atmosphere and longevity of a neighborhood French restaurant just up the street from Mon Petit Café  — Sel et Poivre — a family-run French bistro on Lexington Avenue. This June it will celebrate its 28th Anniversary: same family (husband and wife team, Christian and Pamela Schienle); same location, and same daily specials. Remarkably, it’s also open seven days a week, as well.

2Christian Schienle

Sel et Poivre is a cozy, reasonably priced watering-hole for Upper Eastsiders who enjoy consuming a well-prepared meal at a table with a bit of elbow room, in a quiet dining room only punctuated by the sound of conversation and clinking glasses.  But of course, it’s the food that’s the main draw and the restaurant continues to live up to the timeless standards of classic Bistro dishes – from Skate with lemon and capers and Frog Legs to Duck a l’Orange, Calf’s Liver Lyonnais and Filet Mignon in a red wine shallot sauce. But it’s not limited to those dishes.

lentil soup

Lentil Soup

Last week, as part of a Tasting Menu for the press, hosted by the restaurant, we were offered a range of dishes, some familiar, some not. We began with an excellent Lentil Soup ($9.95), redeemed from blandness by a touch of smoked ham. The table also shared a plate of Wild Boar Pate  ($14.95) served with a dab of red wine mustard and prune compote on the side. If it’s available as a Special, grab it. It’s one of the best things on the menu.  In fact, the restaurant will feature a Game Festival from the end of March to mid-April. And throughout the year, when game is available (largely sourced from Texas), it offers a “wild, fresh and healthy Game Menu,” including Ostrich, which you can view on its website.

salmon

Salmon with White and Green Beans in a White Wine Sauce

Next came a lightly grilled Salmon filet – perfectly cooked – perched on a bed of soft cannellini beans. The dish was punched up with the contrasting crunch of green beans. ($25.95) If you are looking for a simple, elegant and healthy dish, this is for you.

burger

Bistro Burger with French Fries

To my surprise, my favorite main course on this Tasting menu was the Bistro Burger and French Fries. ($16.95) The secret, according to Owner/Chef Schienle, is a 28-year long relationship with his butcher, who delivers the same quality of beef with the same balance of meat and fat, day in and day out. In fact, there was no special ingredient or seasoning that I could discern in this burger. It was simply great meat – almost buttery — perfectly cooked on a perfect bun, with perfect fries. It worked well with an Austrian Red Zweigelt, suggested by the Chef.

Boar

Wild Boar Osso Bucco with Wild Mushroom Risotto

I was of two minds about the Wild Boar Osso Bucco. ($39.95)  I found the shank meat a tad dry, despite its tomato sauce – but I adored the side dish, a meltingly rich Wild Mushroom Risotto. Next time, I will opt for the Risotto with Wild mushrooms and Leeks ($16.95) as a main course.  It’s on both the restaurant’s Lunch and Dinner Menus for a reason.  It’s a total winner.

wine

Zweigelt Austrian Red Wine

Interior

Interior of Restaurant

Of the two desserts sampled, my favorite was the Chocolate Terrine ($9.25), which tasted like pure chocolate, butter and sugar – in short – heaven. The classic Apple Tart ($9.25) was delicious, as well. Hard to go wrong with either of them.

tart

Warm Apple Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream

Chocolate

Chocolate Terrine

There are Prix Fixe lunch, dinner and brunch menus that are definitely a bargain, and for those looking to meet a friend for a drink before or after a movie or day of work, there is a cozy little bar up front.

Sel et Poivre is a wonderful neighborhood restaurant. All you have to do is hop on the recently completed Q line, get off at 63rd Street, and make it your neighborhood hang out, as well.

Photos by Eleanor Foa Dienstag

Sel et Poivre
853 Lexington Avenue (64th and 65th)
212.517.5780
Lunch: Noon – 4p.m., Monday – Friday
Dinner: 4 p.m. – 10:30 p.m., Monday – Thursday
4 p.m. – 11 p.m., Friday- Saturday
4 p.m.-  10 p.m., Sunday
Brunch: Noon – 4 p.m., Saturday – Sunday

About Eleanor Foa Dienstag (109 Articles)
<p>Eleanor Foa Dienstag is a journalist and photojournalist whose work has appeared in The New York Times, Harper’s, the New Republic, the New York Observer, Ms., McCall’s,Travel & Leisure, Frequent Flyer, and many other websites and publications. Eleanor is the author of two nonfiction books: a memoir, “Whither Thou Goest: The Story of An Uprooted Wife,” acclaimed by Business Week for its insights into corporate life; and “In Good Company: 125 Years At The Heinz Table,” a unique view of a quintessential American company. Both books were promoted with national radio and television appearances. Eleanor served as staff speechwriter to the Chairman and CEO of American Express. In 1983, she founded Eleanor Foa Associates (www.eleanorfoa.com). It provides a wide variety of corporate services, including annual reports, executive speeches, corporate histories and marketing materials for profit and not-for-profit organizations. Eleanor is past president of the American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA), received speechwriting awards from IABC, and was awarded literary residencies at Yaddo, and the Virginia Center for the Creative Arts (VCCA). She resides in Manhattan.  </p>