MeToo and Mythology: Medusa Sculpture in NYC Unveils Controversy

*Trigger Warning: Article includes content on rape and sexual violence.

A powerful seven-foot-tall bronze sculpture, placed across from the New York County Criminal Courthouse, titled “Medusa With the Head of Perseus” by Argentine-Italian artist Luciano Garbati has gotten much press, praise, and push back for its commentary on the MeToo Movement.

The work reimagines Italian Renaissance artist Benvenuto Cellini’s sculpture “Perseus with the Head of Medusa.” The mythology story goes as followed: Medusa, a maiden of the temple of Athena, was raped by Olympia God Poseidon. Athena enraged that her temple had been defiled, transformed Medusa into a snake-haired Gorgon whose eyes can turn any onlooker to stone. Later, assisted by the gods the hero Perseus hunted and beheaded Medusa, and thereafter used her head and compelling gaze as a weapon. Depictions of Persues’ victory have been depicted throughout history, including 16th century Cellini’s sculpture, where Perseus stands atop Medusa’s decapitated body displaying her head in triumph.

Luciano Garbati 
Medusa With The Head of Perseus, 2008-2020 
Installed at Collect Pond Park. 
Courtesy of MWTH Project.

Of course, Gabati’s 2020 sculpture reverses the image, depicting a standing Medusa grasping Perseus severed head by his locks. Garbati stated, “How can a triumph be possible if you are defeating a victim.”

This is not the first time Medusa has become a feminist symbol. A logo for Versace, adopted as a personification of the feminine rage, inspiring the hashtag #Me(dusa)too from contemporary artist Judy Takacs. In 2016, Atlantic essayist Elizabeth Johnston even called Medusa “the original Nasty Woman.” Johnston writes, “Medusa has since haunted Western imagination, materializing whenever male authority feels threatened by female agency.”

Now this project organized by the artist-led MWTH Project, in partnership with NYC Parks, brings her presence outside the temple of law where Harvey Weinstein and other offenders stood trial. Garbati writes via Instagram, “The place chosen is not accidental, since there they judge cases for crimes related to violence against women… This sculpture that has became a symbol of justice for many women.”

However, many including Tarana Burke herself have rejected the artist’s commentary on the movement. In response to the New York Times coverage of the piece, Burke, founder of the #MeToo Movement, writes via Instagram: “First, let me say as a survivor, if this feels cathartic to you – I’m not taking anything away from that. However, this Movement is not about retribution or revenge and it’s certainly not about violence. It is about HEALING and ACTION… None of it [the sculpture] is right. This isn’t the kind of symbolism that this Movement needs and honestly, if the sculptor wanted to pay tribute to the ‘me too’ Movement he should have given me a call.”

She goes on to remind others that MeToo is NOT a women’s movement. It is for everyone who has experienced sexual violence, including men and children. Furthermore, stressing the inaccuracy of the statue doubling down on the idea that #MeToo is about hunting down and destroying men, ie “cancel culture”; instead it is striving for a judicial system of accountability and protection for assault survivors. Burke also points readers to the “Break the Silence Memorial” in Minneapolis, which is the first-ever monument to honor and support those who have experienced sexual violence.

While the full-figured Medusa’s wide power stance brings dominance to the female form, some still note how the male-gaze has distorted the presentation – lack of body hair, narrow shoulders and waist disproportionate to breast size and slightly muscular back; and they even question the mythological narrative – why does she have Perseus’ head, not her abuser Poseidon’s.

Feminist activist Wagatwe Wanjuki wrote on Twitter, “#MeToo was started by a Black woman, but a sculpture of a European character by a dude is the commentary that gets centered? Sigh.”

“Medusa With the Head of Perseus?” will be on view at the courthouse until April 30th, 2021. For more information go to the website for MWTH.

Top photo: Bigstock

About Sofia Pipolo (25 Articles)
Sofia Pipolo is an independent journalist and filmmaker based in Brooklyn, NY. Her interest in both media and social outreach allows her to create from a collective and intersectional mindset. Her focus is working with artists, independent businesses, and community organizations; connecting them with established platforms and publications, and creating original content that promotes their brand through journalism, documentary, and creative collaborations. With over 50 articles published, she’s covered stories on art, culture/politics, and independent businesses. On set, Sofia is an invaluable Script Supervisor; and has been interviewed about her role by Woman Around Town. Her most recent projects include Crybaby Bridge, A Stage of Twilight, Maxine, and her own short documentary, Wrestling With Identity.